There's been another of those strange holistic doctor deaths, and this one - if the reportage is to be believed - is one of the strangest of them all, for the individual concerned, Dr. James Winer, appears to have died under circumstances raising lots of questions, with few answers. Here's the article shared by Mr. V.T.:

80th Doctor Dead: Holistic, Prominent and Outspoken

There are certain things to note here, among them Dr. Winer's impeccable academic credentials:

Dr. James Winer is one of the leading pioneers in the natural health field.

For over forty-five years he has been on the cutting edge of the alternative health movement, serving in a wide variety of capacities.

  • Editor of the “Journal of Energy Medicine”
  • Associate Director of the Price-Pottenger Nutrition Research Foundation (a prestigious Foundation founded by two giants in the nutrition field, Dr. Weston Price, DDS and Dr. Francis Pottenger, Jr., MD)
  • Education Director of the Hippocrates Health Institute in San Diego (a residential health center founded by Dr. Ann Wigmore)
  • Director of the National Health Project
  • Convention Director of the National Health Federation


While living in France, he attended the University of Paris.

He graduated Magna Cum Laude from Brandeis University and graduated valedictorian of his class at Life University, where he received his doctorate summa cum laude.

The University of Paris and Brandeis University are hardly fly-by-night institutions, but widely respected "mainstream" academic institutions. Even more to the point, Dr. Winer was apparently well-known in the northeastern Atlantic states and Ohio, being an outspoken radio show host:

He is also the author of books, audio and videotapes, and articles on natural health, instructor of nutrition at a university, fitness instructor at an undergraduate college, and currently the founder and director of the Winer Wellness Center in Pittsburgh, PA.


In addition to teaching and lecturing across the United States, Dr. Winer has appeared on thousands of radio and television programs in Pittsburgh, PA and across the country.

As the article notes, Dr. Winer's office is not taking calls, but is saying he died suddenly of a cardiac arrest while in Florida.

And that's where things get murky:

The circumstances of his death, however, remained shrouded in mystery.

One reader wrote to tell us the following:

“It appears he left on Tuesday for a trip with a friend or to meet up with someone for Thanksgiving and he never returned to Pittsburgh.””

She continued:

My friend and I messaged me (sic) on Saturday after Thanksgiving that he was missing and we were so afraid”
“Then today my (immediate family, name withheld) was at the office and they confirmed he was found yesterday as a John Doe in hospital and they pulled the plug.  No ID on him.  Nothing.”
They continued:
“My (relative at his office- relation omitted) said that everything was out of ordinary, as he checks in, never misses etc. he was a loved doctor on Pitttsburgh and speaks out often against vaccines. “
While Dr Winer was 70, he looked much younger and his patients are writing saying he was a vegetarian for 30 about years we are told. What is confusing is why he was allegedly in Florida with no identification and brought in as a John Doe, as we’d like to find out what really happened.(Emphases in the original.)
Assuming the anonymous report to be true, a number of questions arise: what was a well-known "alternative doctor" doing in Florida, without checking in with his family, traveling and apparently checked into a Florida hospital as a John Doe, i.e., without any identification, where "they pulled the plug." Pulling the plug usually connotes, in this country at least, the idea of someone on life support, and pulling the plug literally means someone, usually family or someone with power of attorney, has taken the decision to end his life. Only in this case, with no identification, one can only assume the family was not involved. So who would do this, and why?
Why indeed? Dr. Winer seems to have two things in common with many of the other mysterious deaths of such "holistic" doctors, a term I don't like, as it connotes people engaged in some sort of speudo-science, rather than doctors engaged in preventative medicine. In Dr. Winer's instance, this appears to be the case, for as the article notes, he like many doctors, was concerned about vaccines, and also concerned with nutrition, and perhaps this indicates that he shared many people's growing concerns about the actual safety of the GMO engineered American food supply, though let it be noted, the article does not state this in so many terms.
Until more is known, one can only speculate. But one thing remains certain, the number of such deaths now seems to have gone beyond any idea that all these deaths are mere coincidence or are a statistical fluke. What must now be discovered is: what was he doing in Florida? Did he travel there with identification, or not? If so, when and how was his identification removed? Who "pulled the plug"? and why? Was he lured to Florida? If so, who lured him, and why? Was he perhaps investigating the Florida deaths of other holistic doctors? Who was the friend Dr. Winer allegedly left with for the Thanksgiving trip?
I don't know about you, but increasingly these deaths strike me as mackerels on moonlit beaches: they both shine, and stink.

Joseph P. Farrell

Joseph P. Farrell has a doctorate in patristics from the University of Oxford, and pursues research in physics, alternative history and science, and "strange stuff". His book The Giza DeathStar, for which the Giza Community is named, was published in the spring of 2002, and was his first venture into "alternative history and science".


  1. basta on December 8, 2017 at 7:22 am

    Well lots of weirdness goes on in Florida; it has a special kind of pervasive, edgy strip-mall seediness that breeds grifters and meth-heads like few other places on earth. Just check out the website “Florida Man,” (think Super Man, Spider Man…) which does nothing more than compile articles with “Florida Man” in the headline, recounting all the insane goings-on there. So it’s the perfect place when you require plausible deniability.

    That said, it’s pretty clear that Big Pharma has its own fixers taking out these naturopaths. Soft-kill for the masses, hard-kill for the trouble-makers. Just another corporate gang terrorizing the besieged public and marking territory.

    • Robert Barricklow on December 8, 2017 at 12:00 pm

      Loved your hard/soft kill analogy.

  2. Joseph P. Farrell on December 8, 2017 at 5:47 am

    Someone in the Pittsburgh area informed me that the doctor had recently bought a home in Florida, and that this is the reason he was there.

  3. DanaThomas on December 8, 2017 at 5:06 am

    Will any “authorities” do a true investigation? Time and again through history power groups have conducted “surgical removal” of key persons they see as a threat…

  4. zendogbreath on December 8, 2017 at 12:19 am

    if i farm livestock, why would i intentionally feed them what i know ruins them? slowly or quickly? what’s the point.

    i used to keep faith in the inevitable rise of intelligence with time. i felt all truth is eventually learned. not so much any more. too many contrary examples. look how long cannabis has been held back.

    do anyone else see folk getting smarter? let alone fast enough? i met a healthcare professional last year. she was pregnant with her first. 2nd trimester her doc recommended she get vaccines for flu, tdap, whatever. she did. never read the package inserts. seemed to have no memory of a decade or two ago when no pregnant woman got any vaccines.

    so where does this all go? what’s the point of doing this to livestock? what’s the point of making livestock more ignorant of their own strengths than they already are? what’s the point of making them sicker?

  5. goshawks on December 7, 2017 at 10:52 pm

    To be a prominent doctor and a ‘vaccine protestor’ could easily be dangerous to your health, but I am going with “Editor of the ‘Journal of Energy Medicine’.” One does not choose to be involved with “Energy Medicine” without being energy-sensitive. This includes at least latent psychic abilities. Now, that would paint a big target on a doctor. This is a ‘dead doctor’ case to follow…

  6. Robert Barricklow on December 7, 2017 at 12:51 pm

    The 21st Century’s “Alexandria Burning” syndrome that’s
    Symbolizing the irretrievable loss of public knowledge.

  7. Enigma3 on December 7, 2017 at 11:54 am

    When this started the key link was interest in GcMAF. Now – I don’t know. It is damn sure obvious to me that the Deep State and Big Pharma does not want a healthy US population. The US appears to be the numero uno example of strategies used by the Rich Bastards to depopulate the country. No doubt this is organized sinister mass murder. The question now is not if, but when will the good guys will start shooting back.
    As an aside, we need to monitor GcMAF treatments in Germany, Switzerland and Japan and what tactics big pharma will use to eliminate GcMAF treatments.

  8. WalkingDead on December 7, 2017 at 9:23 am

    Que Twilight Zone intro, nothing to see here, move along. This is just big Pharma doing business as usual and protecting its profits and globalists agendas.
    I’m sorry, but our business model requires that we “manage” your illness for maximum profit while we kill you off with all those “side effects” (we are especially fond of that “may include death” one).
    There are far too many of you useless eaters out there; and these “doctors” aren’t helping by keeping you alive and healthy. No competition is allowed, they simply have to die.

  9. Cara on December 7, 2017 at 9:02 am

    Wild speculation:
    What if these doctors are being kidnapped / coerced / persuaded to join the breakaway civilization? Perhaps all the tech. wizardry has resulted in some unsolvable-by-conventional-means medical problems which only these alternative modalities can address.

    One would have to investigate if there are open caskets or family identifications of the bodies to see if this idea has any merit.

    (At one stage I did see a list online of scientists (not doctors) who seemed to mysteriously die/disappear and there was speculation they were taken by the breakaways.)

    • WalkingDead on December 7, 2017 at 9:35 am

      “Atlas Shrugged” plot line. Maybe they are ending up on Mars with all those “missing children”. Maybe the “breakaway civilization” has gone interplanetary to ensure their survival of the coming. planned nuclear holocaust in order to eliminate the bulk of humanity. I really don’t think we can put anything past these evil individuals.

    • jenuspect (Jeannette B) on December 7, 2017 at 7:37 pm

      Along similar lines, I’ve wondered if they’ve already provided care to individuals in situations where they might see or need to know things that some are not willing to trust them to keep quiet about.

    • Westcoaster on December 8, 2017 at 5:48 pm

      That’s a great question. Maybe they’re in the same place as all the micro biologists that mysteriously died about a decade ago.

Help the Community Grow

Please understand a donation is a gift and does not confer membership or license to audiobooks. To become a paid member, visit member registration.

Upcoming Events